General information only, not financial advice. Simple Car Insurance is a comparison and information site — not an insurer, broker or financial adviser — and nothing here is a recommendation about a policy or insurer for you. How we make money.
Cover

Can you have two car insurance policies on the same car in NZ?

You can buy two car insurance policies on the same car in New Zealand, but you cannot be paid twice for the same loss. All six wordings we read have an "other insurance" clause: Tower, AA Insurance, Cove and Vero say they won't pay where another policy covers the loss, and AMI and State say you must tell them about it.

Last checked against its sources on 2026-11-05

Can you have two car insurance policies on the same car?

Yes, nothing stops you buying a second policy, and it happens more often than people think: a parent and an adult child both insure the same car, or a new policy starts before the old one is cancelled. But a second policy buys you no extra cover. Each wording tries to make the other policy pay first.

What each wording says about other insurance on the same car (quoted, read 2026-11-05)
InsurerWhat the wording says
Tower (09-24)"This policy does not cover any loss or liability if you're covered for that same loss or liability to any extent under a policy with another insurer. We'll not contribute towards a claim under any other policy."
AA Insurance (Apr 2025)"This policy also does not provide cover where cover is provided by other insurance or by a warranty or guarantee. We will not contribute to any claim made under any other policy."
Cove (08-2025)"Your policy does not cover loss or liability where cover is provided by any other insurance, not provided by us. You must tell us as soon as you are aware of any other insurance that provides the same or similar cover"
Vero (Dec 2025)"We won't pay if you, anyone else, or any organisation covered under this policy, is covered under any other policy, or fails to meet the policy's terms and conditions."
AMI (AMI0052/11)Lists "other insurance covers your vehicle" among the changes you must let it know about
State (SI6737/5)Same wording as AMI: "other insurance covers your vehicle" is a change you must tell it about

Will both insurers pay if I claim on two policies?

No. Tower says it won't cover a loss you are covered for "to any extent" under another insurer's policy, and AA Insurance says it "will not contribute to any claim made under any other policy". The best case is that one insurer pays once, minus its excess. The worst case is two insurers each pointing at the other.

How a court or the ombudsman would settle two clauses that each defer to the other is a legal question this page does not answer, and no insurer's wording answers it either. The practical point is simpler: two policies on one car mean two sets of premiums for one payout, and a claim that can stall while the insurers work out which of them is on risk. Even inside one insurer, AA Insurance limits legal liability to one policy: "If you have cover for your legal liability under any other insurance policy with us, you can only claim this benefit under one policy per event." Tower has the same rule for its own policies.

Do I have to tell my insurer about another policy?

On most policies, yes. AMI and State list "other insurance covers your vehicle" among the things you must tell them as soon as possible, and Cove says "You must tell us as soon as you are aware of any other insurance that provides the same or similar cover". Not telling them is a breach of the policy conditions, which can put a claim at risk.

The insurer will usually ask which policy is meant to be the main one and may suggest cancelling the other. If the second policy covers something the first doesn't, such as a parent's comprehensive policy and a child's own third party policy, say so, and ask each insurer in writing what it would pay in a crash.

How do I switch car insurer without a gap or an overlap?

Start the new policy first, then cancel the old one from the same date. AMI, AA Insurance, Tower and Vero all refund unused premium when you cancel. A short overlap costs nothing extra once the refund comes back, but a gap of even a day leaves the car uninsured and can trigger the new policy's storm and flood stand-down.

Cancelling the old policy: refunds and cooling-off periods (quoted, read 2026-11-05)
InsurerCancel any time?Cooling-off period
AMI"You may cancel your policy at any time by letting us know… We refund any premium paid for the period you have no cover."None stated in the wording
AA InsuranceYes, unless you have claimed for a total loss; "we will refund you any amount we owe after the cancellation date"21 days, if no claim: full refund
Tower"You can cancel this policy by notifying us either online or by phone or email. We'll refund any unused premium."15 days, if no claim: full refund
VeroYes; "we'll refund any premium you've already paid for insurance cover after the cancellation date" if no claim30 days, if no claim: full refund
CoveMonthly policy: cancel online in My Cove14 days, if no claim or loss: full refund

The stand-down is the reason not to leave a gap. Tower's wording excludes "any storm, flood, wildfire, tsunami, volcanic activity, or landslide that occurs within 72 hours of the start date of this policy", and Cove has a 48-hour version for natural disaster, storm, flood, wildfire or landslip. Both say the stand-down does not apply if the new policy "started immediately after another policy that covered" those risks, or if it was taken out when you bought the car. Start the new cover the same day the old one ends, never the day after.

A worked example: switching insurer with an overlap, or with a gap

Illustrative only: the premiums and dates are made up, and the stand-down is Tower's. Two drivers each move from an old insurer to Tower. The old policy costs $1,200 a year, paid annually, with six months left. Heavy rain floods a street on day two of the new policy and both cars are damaged.

Illustrative: the same switch, done two ways
Driver A: new cover starts, old cancelled from the same dateDriver B: cancels the old policy, starts the new one two days later
Old policy refundUnused premium, roughly $600 for six monthsUnused premium, roughly $600
Cover on the day of the floodTower, from the start dateTower, but inside its 72-hour stand-down
Does the stand-down apply?No: the policy started immediately after another that covered floodYes: there was a two-day gap
Likely resultFlood claim handled, minus the excessFlood damage excluded; Driver B pays for it

If Driver A had let the two policies run side by side for a week, the extra cost would only have been the old insurer's premium for that week, and the refund for it would follow the cancellation date. Overlap is cheap. A gap is the expensive mistake.

Is a parent and child both insuring the same car double insurance?

Yes, if both policies name the same car. It usually happens by accident: a parent keeps the car on the family policy after the child buys their own. Pick one policy, tell it who the main driver really is, and cancel the other. Naming the parent as main driver when the child mostly drives is fronting, which is a bigger problem than the overlap.

How one policy can cover a car that someone else owns or mostly drives is covered in car insurance in someone else's name, and the rules for younger drivers in car insurance under 25.

Does my own policy cover me when I drive someone else's car?

Sometimes, but only after the owner's insurance. AMI and State cover your legal liability in another vehicle only if "the liability is not covered under any other insurance", and Cove covers liability in a borrowed car "that's not covered by other insurance". None of them pays for damage to the car you are driving.

So if you borrow a friend's car and crash it, their policy is the one that responds first, including for damage to their car if they have comprehensive cover. Their excess is theirs to pay unless you agree otherwise, and AMI's wording says it does "not cover the excess under any other insurance".

Questions

Is it illegal to have two car insurance policies in NZ?

No. Nothing stops you buying two policies on the same car, but none of the six NZ wordings we read will pay twice for one loss, and AMI, State and Cove say you must tell them about the other insurance.

Can I claim on two car insurance policies for the same accident?

Not to be paid twice. Tower, AA Insurance, Cove and Vero all exclude a loss that another policy covers, so you will be paid once at most, and the insurers may dispute which of them pays.

Do I get a refund if I cancel my car insurance early?

Yes, for the unused part of the premium: AMI, AA Insurance, Tower and Vero all say so. Cove is monthly, so you stop paying when you cancel. AA Insurance (21 days), Tower (15), Cove (14) and Vero (30) also refund everything if you cancel within their cooling-off period without a claim.

Should my new car insurance start before I cancel the old one?

Yes. Start the new policy, then cancel the old one from the same date. A gap leaves the car uninsured, and on Tower and Cove a new policy that does not start straight after another one has a 72- or 48-hour stand-down for storm and flood.

Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we’ll fix it or mark it unchecked. We aim to do that within 5 working days.

Sources

Read on 2026-09-16. If a source and this page disagree, the source is right.

Related